Diet and Cancer

There was a time as a physician when I was less interested in diet.  After taking my board exams three years ago, I decided to confront diet once and for all.  I embarked on an educational journey to determine specific instructions for patients with certain medical conditions.  Though I was already aware of the effect of food on the treatment of high blood pressure and diabetes, I was uninformed about its effect on cancer risk. I touched on this a bit in my last post.  This post will dig into this topic a bit more.    The China study fully informed me of the relationship between food and cancer.

In the 1980s, the China study looking into death rates and cause of death in China spanning 20 years.  These rates were mapped and grouped into geographical areas.  The study concluded that coastal provinces were noted to have the highest incidence of cancer; whereas, cancer rates were nonexistent in the rural provinces.  Incidentally, the coastal areas included wealthy big cities like Shanghai and Beijing and their eating habits were different.  They consumed much more meat, eggs, and dairy than those in the rural provinces.  Meanwhile those in the rural areas were not vegan or vegetarian, but they ate significantly less meat protein due to cost.  For example, they would split one chicken breast  in a rice dish 30 ways to feed 30 people.

Of course the China Study analyzed several variables in order to accurately isolate and capture the effect of multiple lifestyle factors.  And naturally, a diet low  in meat protein was most highly correlated with prolonged life span.

The China Study was a powerful analysis with very interesting results.  It was something that was omitted from my education.  I suggest looking at the documentary entitled Forks Over Knives, and then checking out the book to further flesh out the details.

Is Eating Clean Necessary?

I just finished reading this article and I thought it raised some very interesting points.  The writer does an excellent job of discussing several misconceptions about food.  I actually do agree that celiac disease (gluten or wheat sensitivity or intestinal allergy), and  monosodium glutamate (MSG) are overblown compared to their actual level of incidence and disease severity.   Genetically modified foods are an unknown quantity. There are three points that need to analyzed.

He notes that “in some studies, processed red meat in large amounts is associated with an increased relative risk of developing cancer. The absolute risk, however, is often quite small. If I ate an extra serving of bacon a day, every day, my lifetime risk of colon cancer would go up less than one-half of 1 percent. Even then, it’s debatable.”   Though it is not well-publicized, pork and red meat have a known association with certain cancers.  The incidence of colon cancer is higher though it is nowhere near as high as the  association  between lung cancer and cigarette smoking.

He is correct on this, but he singles out just one issue.  Heart attacks, strokes and diabetes are also associated with  moderate meat consumption.  Cancer was his large point and I intend to discuss this in a later post, but he neglects to mention how diet causes two of the most common chronic illnesses in America.  Dirty fuel is the direct link to both cancer, diabetes, and heart disease in America.

The next issue is that the author notes that being afraid of food is a problem.  It is important to keep this in a certain context.  You will do better than most if you ensure that 90% of your food is clean fuel.  Doing so will ensure that you are not necessarily vegan, but you will be what Dr. Joel Fuhrman refers to as a nutritarian.

And last, but not least, the author is an Pediatrician  and researcher at Indiana University School of Medicine.  Many university researchers seek grants from large corporations to perform food industry-friendly research and receive large payments in exchange for pushing certain narratives.  His viewpoint differs from mine in that I am an internist who sees cancer, diabetes, and heart disease on a daily basis. He is a pediatrician and has limited daily exposure to the long-term effects of these chronic conditions.